We research & test to recommend the best products; see our review process here. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn a commission.

We Tested The 6 Best Bark Collars for Behavioral Training!

Excessive and inappropriate barking is one of the most challenging habits to manage in dogs. So, how do you put a stop to this behavior? A bark collar is one option.

A bark collar is a type of dog training collar that is used on a dog that barks excessively. It’s meant to deter the dog from barking and, over time, make it less inclined to do so.

It is completely safe to train your dog using a no-bark training collar.

Bark collars might be intimidating at first, but after you’ve found the correct one for you and your dog, you’ll be more comfortable using it.

When it comes to bark collars, picking the best one may be challenging, but understanding what to look for can make all the difference.

Fortunately, we’re here to make things easy for you.

We tested the top 25 bark collars on the market with our dogs and narrowed them down to the top 6 picks plus three honorable mentions.

Our Top Picks

  Product Details    
01 DogCare Bark Collar Best Overall: DogCare Bark Collar This DogCare collar is an obvious choice for anyone who wants to correct their dog’s excessive barking without spending too much time training. Check Price
02 Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar Best With Remote: Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar This dog training collar includes three training modes to help you teach your dog basic obedience commands while addressing unmanageable behavior issues. Check Price
03 NBJU Rechargeable Bark Collar Best For Sensitivity: NBJU Rechargeable Bark Collar This bark collar has three distinct training modes and seven different sensitivity settings. Because of its dual layer of defense, it is one of the most effective on the market. Check Price
04 PetSafe Remote Pet Spray Trainer Best Spray Collar: PetSafe Remote Pet Spray Trainer PetSafe has over 30 years of expertise and has proven its dedication to the well-being of pets all across the world. This pet spray collar is just one more reason why pet owners continue to put their faith in them. Check Price
05 DogRook Bark Collar Best Budget: DogRook Bark Collar The DogRook Bark Collar is a great all-around training collar that is both humane and affordable. Check Price
06 Modus Bark Control Device Best Ultrasonic Collar: Modus Bark Control Device The Modus Bark Control Device is a 2-in-1 ultrasonic anti-barking tool for dog training that is both safe and effective. The device is capable of training your pets to stop undesired behavior. Check Price

Disclaimer

Before opting for shock collar use, we recommend obedience training as your initial response to unwanted behavior.

Training your dog can prevent the potential stress of a shock collar, and is a more positive way of preventing bad behavior. 

Using a shock collar should only be considered if obedience training fails or if you have an exceptionally stubborn, large, or aggressive dog.

While shock collars aren’t meant to be used as a cruel punishment, and have been suggested by trainers to get the attention of tough cases, for some dogs they can cause emotional distress.

Check out brain training techniques, a science-backed way to improve your dog’s behavior without the use of force or dominance!

How We Selected The Best Bark Collars

Dog wearing a bark collar
When used alongside positive reinforcement, bark collars are a safe and effective way to deter unwanted barking.

When picking a collar for testing, we opted for brands known for manufacturing high-quality dog products, such as PetSafe.

They are one of the industry’s most trusted brands. They have decades of experience helping dog owners like you find solutions for canine behavior modification. 

Next, we looked at the best-rated dog bark collars that dog owners were raving about and compiled a list of them.

We examined pricing and availability recommendations from well-known websites like Amazon and Chewy.

We narrowed our list to 25 of the best bark collars currently on the market and brought them home to put them to the test with our dogs.

From those 25, we chose 6 bark collars for our top picks and 3 for honorable mention.

Read More: The Most Popular Collar Types. Here are the most popular types of collars for dogs of all sizes and their uses!

Best Bark Collars Reviewed

1. Best Overall: Dog Care Bark Collar

DogCare Bark Collar

Product Ratings

Affordability5/5
Comfort 4/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Sizing 4/5
Quality 5/5

Dimension: 3.2 x 1.8 x 1.82 inches | Color: Black | Brand: Dog Care | Material: Nylon | Features: Bark Sensor | Dogs: Extra Small to Extra Large Breeds

What We Liked

  • Automatic bark sensor
  • Adjustable sensitivity levels
  • Easy-to-read battery indication
  • Extra parts included
  • Adjustable strap

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not waterproof
  • Not for dogs with thick coat

With Dog Care’s Bark Collar, you can safely and effectively train your dog to stop barking.

You may switch between the two training modes at any time by pushing a button.

This anti-barking shock collar features a sensitivity option so you can tailor it to your specific commands.

Keep in mind that an anti-bark collar may work for some dogs, but others may require a softer correction. We recommend you watch your dog to see how he responds.

This collar automatically detects your dog’s barking behaviors to ensure no false positives.

This is beneficial if you have neighboring dogs that bark because they won’t be able to trigger the collar.

This collar will keep your dog from barking excessively if you have to leave him behind while you’re at work or out of town.

Size

You can adjust this bark collar to fit smaller and larger dogs.

We did observe, however, that it did not work as well on dogs with thicker coats. 

You may need to adjust the sensitivity settings if your dog’s coat is thicker. It may appear a little bulky on smaller dogs, but it’s still an effective collar. 

Materials & Features

This bark collar is made of nylon and has a plastic clasp on the side. The battery level on the collar is easily visible.

An added bonus with this collar is the long-lasting battery life thanks to the sleep mode function.

The collar is not waterproof, which is a disadvantage. Avoid electrocution by being cautious around water or removing the collar if your dog will be near water.

Ease of Use

The side-squeeze buckle on this collar makes it simple to slip on and off.

When you first set it up, all you have to do is insert the battery to get it started. There’s no technical setup on your part to use this bark collar.

Adjusting the sensitivity level is a simple process with the click of a button.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

2. Best With Remote Control: Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar

Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar

Product Ratings

Affordability5/5
Comfort 4/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Sizing 4/5
Quality 4/5

Dimension: 4.6 x 1.69 x 7.87 inches | Color: Black | Brand: Dog Care | Material: Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene | Features: Remote Control | Dogs: 15lbs to 110lbs

What We Liked

  • 3 training modes
  • Remote control
  • Security keypad lock
  • Remote can control training for up to 3 dogs
  • Rechargeable

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not waterproof
  • Not for dogs with thick coats
  • Remote is big

This bark collar includes three training modes: an audible beep, a static shock, and a vibration mode.

This deters your dog from barking excessively while wearing it. Alter your dog’s training methods to find what works best for him.

This device can accommodate up to three collars on a single transmitter for multiple dogs. This allows you to fix behavior without having to buy a whole set for each dog.

You won’t have any trouble walking your dogs in a large park because the wireless range is 350 feet long. The battery has a runtime of 15 days and a standby time of 45 days.

This training collar is an excellent tool for a range of training goals, like teaching your dog to obey under certain circumstances and refraining from barking excessively.

Size

This bark collar can be adjusted to fit smaller and larger breeds. Plus, the straps can easily be shortened by cutting them.

While this collar may appear large on a small dog, it performs well enough to ignore the bulkiness so you can teach your dog to stop barking persistently

Materials & Features

Despite the device’s effectiveness, the collar’s material is thin and prone to fraying and breaking. Given this, we would have preferred a more durable design.

The ability to recharge the gadget eliminates the need to purchase batteries, which is a fantastic feature.

Both the remote and the collar are rechargeable and have extended battery lives. For 4 to 5 days, the battery does not even need to be charged, which is impressive.

The collar is water-resistant, according to the manufacturer, although it is not completely waterproof. As a result, it is not advised that you use this collar in the pool.

Ease of Use

Using this collar is a breeze thanks to the clear instructions provided by the manufacturer.

It’s simple to switch between training modes because each has a designated button on the remote.

When using the device with multiple dogs, switching between them is straightforward.

We also appreciate the lock button because it prevents accidental shocks.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

3. Best for Sensitivity: NBJU Rechargeable Bark Collar 

NBJU Rechargeable Bark Collar

Product Ratings

Affordability4/5
Comfort 4/5
Effectiveness 4/5
Sizing 4/5
Quality 5/5

Dimension: 2.76 x 1.46 x 1.57 inches | Color: Various | Brand: NBJU | Material: Leather and Silicone | Features: Silicone Protective Covers | Dogs: Small to Large Breeds

What We Liked

  • 30 minute charging time
  • Up to 12 to 15 days battery life
  • Extra pair of silicone protective covers
  • Waterproof

What We Didn’t Like

  • Times out frequently
  • Setting was difficult to set
  • Bark detection can be too sensitive

This bark collar features three training modes to keep your dog from barking excessively while wearing it. It features seven sensitivity levels.

So, regardless of your dog’s size, the correction will be appropriate.

The built-in USB rechargeable battery in this bark collar only takes 30 minutes to charge. Once the battery is charged, it can last up to 12–15 days before recharging. 

One feature we like is the collar’s 64 training modes to redirect excessive barking. The different modes on this collar may improve your ability to train your dog in obedience. 

Size

Because this bark collar has adjustable straps, it may be suitable for large and small dog breeds. 

It may look big on small dogs, but it isn’t as substantial as some other bark collars on the market today.

Materials & Features

This bark collar has a sleek design with an LCD screen and includes two extra sets of silicone protective covers to help preserve your dog’s skin while addressing unwanted behaviors.

They offer both leather and silicone collars that come in a variety of colors, so you can choose the best one to fit your lifestyle.

This waterproof bark collar ensures your dog’s safety by preventing accidental water-induced shocks.

Ease of Use

Putting this collar on or taking it off is easy, but setting the device up is a little challenging.

The settings are difficult to adjust, and the sensitivity is somewhat hard to gauge at the perfect level to use.

However, we really like that the battery charges so fast and lasts a very long time.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

4. Best Spray Collar: PetSafe Remote Pet Spray Trainer 

PetSafe Remote Pet Spray Trainer

Product Ratings

Affordability3/5
Comfort 4/5
Effectiveness 4/5
Sizing 4/5
Quality 3/5

Dimension: 5.88 x 2.5 x 8.19 inches | Color: Navy | Brand: PetSafe | Material: Nylon | Features: 3-in-1 Training Mode | Dogs: Small to Large Breeds

What We Liked

  • 3 training options
  • Waterproof
  • Rechargeable

What We Didn’t Like

  • Need to be charged constantly
  • Remote is difficult to use

You might feel uncomfortable with the prospect of shocking your furry friend with a static charge, but there are vibration-only collars or ones that solely transmit sound.

If you have a dog with behavioral issues like excessive barking, there are alternative solutions available.

PetSafe’s spray-and-audible no-bark collar is a humane training solution that allows you to go about your day without worrying about inflicting pain and distress on your dog.

You can choose between citronella and unscented spray cartridges. However, citronella is repulsive to dogs, so make sure yours isn’t bothered by the citrus scent. 

Size

In terms of size, the dog’s neck must be at least 8 inches around. Given this, this collar is not appropriate for small dog breeds.

It’s better suited for larger dog breeds with necks up to 28 inches around.

Materials & Features

This collar is lightweight, compact, and waterproof, so you can leave it on your dog for hours without it bothering him.

Keep in mind that no-bark collars should not be left on your dog for more than 12 hours. The battery runs for 40 hours, and each cartridge contains 35 measured sprays.

The citronella spray comprises 1% citronella oil and 99.9% aerosol filler, an odorless and scentless gas used in most aerosols to help them pressurize effectively.

This aerosol filler is used solely in the unscented version.

The nylon collar is poorly constructed and prone to breaking. We would have liked it more if it were constructed from a more durable material.

Ease of Use

This collar’s functionality is decent, but it is tough to use. The button arrangement on the remote is awkward and inconvenient, and you’ll have to push hard to use the device. 

The battery and remote control require frequent charging. We also found the price of cartridges to be steep, and replacing the canisters is time-consuming.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

5. Best Budget: DogRook Bark Collar 

DogRook Bark Collar

Product Ratings

Affordability5/5
Comfort 4/5
Effectiveness 4/5
Sizing 4/5
Quality 3/5

Dimension: 2.8 x 1 x 1.6 inches | Color: Blue | Brand: DogRook | Material: Nylon | Features: Rechargeable | Dogs: Small to Large Breeds

What We Liked

  • 14 days of battery life
  • Training mode switches automatically
  • Rechargeable
  • Extra parts included

What We Didn’t Like

  • Cheap collar material

With this non-static shock collar, you can choose between audible beeps or vibrations.

To quickly train your dog to stop barking when it’s not essential, utilize high-pitched tones and a range of vibration levels.

When in automated mode, this anti-bark collar combines sounds and vibrations to effectively and safely stop your dog from barking.

Barks preceded by vibrations are distinct from barks preceded by a sound signal. When you’re gone from home and your dog is alone, this is a great tool.

It will automatically switch between beeping and vibrating depending on how much your dog barks. 

Remote-controlled training collars are an excellent tool, but carrying the remote might be inconvenient.

While you keep your hands free, this smart collar will discreetly correct your dog’s excessive barking.

Read More: Best Vibrating Collars. If shock collars aren’t up your ally, we tested the best vibrating collars for a less startling means of training.

Size

Dogs weighing between 8 and 110 pounds will benefit from this collar, and the collar’s 9–22-inch neck range provides a wide range of sizing options.

The collar can be adjusted to fit most dog breed sizes, and the plastic prongs should not cause any discomfort to your dog’s skin.

Materials & Features

You won’t have to worry about your dog getting wet while out for a walk with the water-resistant strap.

The strap is lightweight, so it won’t strain your dog’s neck. However, the strap and closure are flimsy and easily broken. 

The collar’s battery life is roughly 14 days, with two to three hours of recharge.

Ease of Use

This collar is simple to set up. We appreciate that it’s effective and hassle-free even with the low price point.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

6. Best Ultrasonic Collar: Modus Bark Control Device

Modus Bark Control Device

Product Ratings

Affordability5/5
Comfort 5/5
Effectiveness 3/5
Sizing 5/5
Quality 3/5

Dimension: ‎ 5.47 x 2.83 x 1.65 inches | Color: Black | Brand: MODUS | Material: Plastic | Features: Ultrasonic | Dogs: Extra Small to Extra Large Breeds

What We Liked

  • Suitable for all breed sizes
  • Simple to use
  • Ultrasonic

What We Didn’t Like

  • Will not work on dogs with hearing impairment
  • Only works if you are present with your dog

This is a handheld device, so it may not be the best option if you need to leave your dog alone. If you need a device for hands-on training, however, this is an excellent option.

This training tool runs on AA batteries, has a long lifespan, and provides broader coverage than the competition.

You can fully control your dog when indoors or outdoors and make sure he doesn’t bother the neighbors.

Correction is delivered in the form of an ultrasonic noise that bothers your dog without harming his ears and is undetectable to human ears.

So, if you don’t like the idea of static shock collars but need a quick fix for bad dog behavior, give the Modus a try.

Size

Because you will not be placing this device around your pet’s neck, it will work on all breeds of dogs.

It is a hand-held device that measures 5.47 x 2.83 x 1.65 inches and weighs 2.56 ounces.

Materials & Features

This ultrasonic device is made of plastic and powered by AA batteries. Your dog will be annoyed, but his ears won’t be damaged by the ultrasonic noise.

The device is small enough to fit in your hand and has an anti-static wrist strap, so you can easily carry it while walking your dog.

Ease of Use

It’s difficult for the sound to get through obstacle material, so make sure you have a clear line of sight when using the tool to train your dog.

Modus anti-bark collar is simple to use and emits sounds once you hold the button down. The button design also prevents accidental pressing.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

Comparison Chart

ProductsBest OverallBest With Remote ControlBest for SensitivityBest Spray CollarBest BudgetBest Ultrasonic Collar
Overall Rating4.6/54.4/54.2/53.5/54/54.2/5
Affordability5/55/54/53/55/55/5
Comfort4/54/54/54/54/55/5
Effectiveness5/55/54/54/54/53/5
Sizing4/54/54/54/54/55/5
Quality5/54/55/54/53/53/5

The Winner

We were impressed with Dog Care’s Bark Collar. This collar is budget-friendly and excellent in terms of quality and effectiveness.

We also appreciate the sensitivity level is adjustable to fit the individual needs of your dog.

Read More: Best Bark Collars for Small Dogs. If you have a small dog, these bark collars may be a better fit. Be sure to check them out!

How To Choose The Best Bark Collars

Consider You and Your Dog’s Needs

Your dog’s size, coat type, and unwanted behavioral issues are factors to consider when choosing the best anti-bark collars.

You also need to consider what type of training and correction you are comfortable with. 

Devices that emit sounds or sprays are options if you aren’t opposed to the idea of causing unease in your dog.

It helps to make a decision based on both your and your dog’s needs.

Read More: Should I Leave My Dog’s Collar On at Night? It depends on your dog and its collar type. We go over the pros and cons of leaving it on and taking it off!

What Kinds of Bark Collars Are Available?

The following are the various types of no-bark training collars:

Vibration Collar

A vibration collar has sensors that detect excessive barking and do not cause distress in your dog. An alternative method of training him is to use a gentle vibrating pulse.

Ultrasonic Device

A collar or handheld device that’s designed to emit an ultrasonic sound is undetectable to you but irritating to your dog. This type of collar uses pain-free corrections.

Static Shock Collar

Static shock training collars are popular but are not ideal for every pet owner.

The good news is you have plenty of non-static anti-bark options if you don’t want to train your dog using static correction.

Onboard sensors are similar to vibration devices because they detect the movement of your dog’s vocal cords.

This type of anti-bark device uses a gentle static shock instead of a vibration. 

Read More: Can You Put a Shock Collar On a Puppy? If so, how long can you leave it on? These are the questions we answer in this guide!

Spray Collar

Spray collars release a metered dose of citronella spray or unscented liquid on the snout when your dog barks excessively.

Citrus scents are repulsive to most dogs, but this training collar is best for small dogs. 

Make sure to account for the cost of replacing spray cartridges because you’ll need a large supply with this training collar.

Read More: If you’re interested in learning more about shock collar training, read How Does a Dog Shock Collar Work?

Honorable Mentions

Here’s a quick rundown of the 3 bark collars that made our honorable mention section.

1. Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Rechargeable Dog Training Collar – Considered for Overall

The BarkLimiter from Garmin detects barking by measuring vibrations in your dog’s throat.

This reduces the chance of false positives and ensures the best possible experience for you and your canine companion.

Autorise is a convenient plug-and-play option to minimize your pet’s exposure to static shocks.

It starts by correcting your dog’s behavior and stops once it becomes effective. We found this anti-bark collar to be gentle, effective, and inexpensive.

2. PetYeah Dog Bark Collar – Considered for Sensitivity

PetYeah’s Dog Bark Collar has accurate recognition with 5 sensitivity levels to minimize false positives. PetYeah doesn’t recommend this collar for aggressive dogs.

WARNING: Do not use this collar for more than 12 hours at a time. For more info, check out our article, How Long Can My Dog Wear a Correction Collar For?

This collar is great for training dogs with normal temperaments at a reasonable price.

Given the device has limitations for temperament and time, we recommend the NBJU Rechargeable Bark Collar for those who need to leave their dogs for more than 12 hours.

3. PetSafe Remote Dog Training Collar – Considered for Remote Control

PetSafe’s Remote Dog Training Collar is designed for necks measuring 6 to 23 inches around and is suitable for dogs weighing 8 pounds and up. 

You can train your dog at home, in the yard, or at the park with the 300-foot range collar. Both the collar and remote are waterproof.

The price is high compared to Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar. The range on this collar is 1000+ feet.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 4.2 / 5. Vote count: 20

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

BarkVa is reader supported. When you buy through a link on our site we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate, BarkVa earns from qualifying purchases.

Jesse Hopping, CCDT

Jesse is a natural-born dog-lover certified dog trainer (CCDT), dog foster, and former volunteer at Richmond SPCA and surrounding dog shelters for over 10 years. Her pack includes a Bernedoodle and 3 Boston Terriers. She’s sipping caramel coffee and watching her pack play in the sun when she’s not writing blogs. Jesse has her Certified Dog Trainer designation from CATCH Canine Trainers Academy since 2018 and and majored in English from the University of Virginia.

You can read more about me in our about us page

Connect with me:

Leave a Comment