We research & test to recommend the best products; see our review process here. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn a commission.

8 Best Indestructible Dog Toys for Heavy Chewers Tested!

Dogs are naturally playful animals. It’s a great way for them to release energy, relieve stress, and bond with their human companions. To our four-legged friends, anything can become a toy, from sticks they find lying on the ground, to shoes and household items that may catch their eye. 

The best way to prevent your precious footwear and household items from becoming Fido’s new favorite chew toy, however, is to give them something that they’ll appreciate and enjoy more than those items, and something that will last longer, to boot!

It is important to note that no dog toy is truly indestructible. The life of a chew toy is perilous and rough. The toys on this list, however, are ready to stand up to the rowdiest play and provide your dog maximum enjoyment, and many of them even come with lifetime guarantees and can be replaced if the need were to arise! 

Let’s jump right into our picks for the best indestructible toys for your dog!

Our Top Picks

  Product Details    
Best-Overall-KONG-Extreme-Dog-Toy Best Overall: KONG Extreme Dog Toy The KONG Extreme Dog Toy is a great, incredibly durable treat-dispensing toy for dogs of all sizes. It’s incredibly durable and dishwasher-safe for when playtime is done. Check Price
Best-Pull-Toy-Goughnuts-Virtually-Indestructible-Dog-Pull-Toy Best Pull Toy: Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Dog Pull Toy If your dog loves to play tug-o-war, then this pull toy will definitely stand up to the fiercest sessions you’ll have. Check Price
Best-Fetch-Toy-Wingpet-Indestructible-Dog-Chew-Toy Best Fetch Toy: Wingpet Indestructible Dog Chew Toy The Wingpet Indestructible Dog Chew Toy is a 4-way bone with a treat-dispensing well in the center so your dog will be rewarded for going to fetch every time. Check Price
Best-Ball-Toy-Ultra-Durable-Dog-Ball Best Ball Toy: Ultra-Durable Dog Ball The unique design of the Ultra-Durable Dog Ball provides extra chase for your dog after it lands, and dispenses treats to keep them chasing it for hours on end. Check Price
Best-Teeth-Cleaning-Toy-ZHEBU-Dog-Chew-Toy Best Teeth Cleaning Toy: ZHEBU Dog Chew Toy The ZHEBU Dog Chew Toy not only provides your dog with hours of entertainment, but it also does an excellent job of cleaning their teeth and promoting oral health at the same time. Check Price
Best-Flying-Disc-Toy-KONG-Flyer-Durable-Rubber-Flying-Disc-Dog-Toy Best Flying Disc Toy: KONG – Flyer – Durable Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy Another outstanding product from KONG, this ruggedly durable flying disc comes in 2 different sizes and multiple colors and can stand up to the test of the toughest play with your dog.  Check Price
Best-Small-Breed-Toy-Nylabone-X-Shaped-Dog-Bone Best Small Breed Toy: Nylabone X-Shaped Dog Bone Nylabone is known for its outstanding toys, and this 4-way bone comes in sizes for small and large breeds, as well as teething puppies, all while cleaning teeth and building strong gums.  Check Price
Best-All-Natural-Toy-White-Tail-Naturals-Huge-Water-Buffalo-Bully-Horn Best All-Natural Toy: White Tail Naturals Huge Water Buffalo Bully Horn Sourced from 100% free-range water buffalo, these all-natural horns provide a long-lasting high protein, low-fat toy to snack on and play with that all dogs will love from start to finish. Check Price

How We Chose the Best Indestructible Dog Toys

Dog running with chew toy
The best indestructible dog toys will hold up to even the heaviest chewers.

The first thing we looked at when rating these products was the price. You’re not going to break the bank buying dog toys, but the prices on some of the items on this list will definitely stick out compared to some of the discount toys you may have purchased in the past. 

We made sure these toys lived up to their price tag, so you and your four-legged companion get what you pay for. 

Next, we carefully looked at the quality of each product. This is, after all, a list of indestructible dog toys, and we put each of these through the paces to make sure they stood up to the roughest and rowdiest play and most fierce and aggressive chewing.

Effectiveness was another factor that we used in assessing these toys. An effective toy is one that dogs want to play with and come back to time after time. They also serve other purposes such as teeth cleaning, treat dispensing, and how much physical activity they get from dogs during playtime.

Finally, we looked at the fun factor of each toy. How much our dogs (and us!) enjoyed playing with them, and how much of a challenge it was for us to get our dogs to put them down. Fun toys will help keep dogs active and healthy while giving them an incentive not to form potentially destructive biting habits.

Read our related article on How to Clean Dog Toys With Ease. Keep smells and bacteria away with our quick guide to cleaning dog toys!

Best Indestructible Dog Toys Reviewed

1. Best Overall: KONG Extreme Dog Toy

 Product Ratings

Price 5/5
Quality 5/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Fun Factor4/5

Sizes: Small (4 x 2.75 x 2.75 inches; 6.88 Ounces) – XXL (6 x 3.88 x 3.88 inches; 1 Pound) | Brand: KONG | Toy Style: Throwing, Gnawing | Features: Dishwasher Friendly, Treat Dispensing | Dogs: Small to Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • Multipurpose toy your pooch will love chewing, chasing, and fetching
  • Dishwasher-friendly so no hassle with clean-up
  • Backed by vets worldwide as a healthy and safe dog toy
  • Can be filled with treats to keep your dog even more engaged

What We Didn’t Like

  • The fiercest dogs might chew their way through over time

The KONG brand has a wide variety of great dog toys, but we’re limiting ourselves to just one today in the form of this Extreme toy.

Sized from small through XXL, you should easily find something strong enough for the most aggressive canine chewers. This Extreme model is finished in black rubber and is specifically designed for power chewers.

It’s not just giving your pup’s jaws and teeth a workout where this toy excels, though. With Extreme, your dog will stay stimulated, not bored. He can also sharpen his digging and hiding skills, while the toy can even help if he’s suffering from separation anxiety.

Best of all, when your furball is done playing, just slip this toy into the dishwasher and you’re good to go.

Now, to save us repeating ourselves, you’ll find user reviews from some disgruntled pet owners suggesting that their hound destroyed this toy just like most of the others we review. You know your dog’s behavior better than anyone, so bear this in mind: if he wrecks every toy he touches, chances are he’ll tear his way through this one as well.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON SEE PRICE ON CHEWY

2. Best Pull Toy: Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Dog Pull Toy

 Product Ratings

Price 3/5
Quality 5/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Fun Factor5/5

Sizes: Medium (9 x 6 x 1.38 inches; 13.6 Ounces)  Large (6 x 3 x 11 inches; 1.64 Pounds) | Brand: Goughnuts | Toy Style: Throwing, Gnawing, Pulling | Features: Made From FDA Approved Food Grade Rubber | Dogs: Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • Great for larger breeds
  • Made from FDA food-grade rubber
  • Guaranteed for life

What We Didn’t Like

  • Some reported breakage
  • Noticeably more expensive than other entries on this list

If you have a larger breed and your dog is also an aggressive chewer, you may be tearing your hair out in the search for an indestructible dog toy. The Goughnuts Store is stuffed with items like this dog pull toy that should keep power chewers from destroying it without causing any damage to their teeth.

The toy is made from food-grade rubber that’s approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), so you have no health or safety concerns here.

The vast bulk of user testimony concerning this toy is positive. We found some isolated complaints about dogs breaking the toys, but this is almost inevitable with the power in the jaws of some breeds. There really is no such thing as a completely indestructible dog toy, but this is the next best thing.

Made in the USA by a family-run company, you can buy with complete confidence and inject some fun into Fido’s playtime without worrying about him chewing it into tiny pieces.

If you’re still in any doubt, this toy comes guaranteed for life by the manufacturer, meaning you have literally nothing to lose.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

3. Best Fetch Toy: Wingpet Indestructible Dog Chew Toy

 Product Ratings

Price 5/5
Quality 4/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Fun Factor5/5

Size: 7.56 x 7.28 x 3.9 inches; 14.89 Ounces (Package Size)| Brand: Wingpet | Toy Style: Throwing, Gnawing, Pulling | Features: Treat Dispensing Toy | Dogs: Medium To Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • 4 way bone design makes this toy easy to throw, and have a tug-o-war with your pooch
  • Made from high quality rubber
  • Great for doggie dental health

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not suited for extreme bite aggressiveness 
  • Smaller treats sometimes fall out of the dispenser during play

This Wingpet 4-way bone treat-dispensing toy is a great toy, especially for playing fetch with, or if your dog enjoys playing tug-o-war. The 4 way bone makes it an easy and fun toy to throw for your dog to chase after, and allows you to pull from multiple directions with ease, providing hours of fun for both you and your dog. 

The durable yet soft rubber that this toy is made from is a great way to improve your dog’s dental health during playtime. It can help clean your dog’s mouth, leading to a reduction in bad doggy breath while helping reduce plaque and tartar buildup on teeth. It’s also a great way to stimulate gum health.

The treat dispensing compartment in the middle of the toy will keep your dog entertained while playing with this toy and is versatile enough to be filled with a wide variety of treats to make this toy your dog’s go-to whenever it’s playtime, even if you’re not around.

It is made of food-grade quality rubber and is 100% safe to chew and gnaw on for hours of enjoyment! 

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

4. Best Ball Toy: Ultra-Durable Dog Ball

 Product Ratings

Price 3/5
Quality 5/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Fun Factor4/5

Size: About 4 Inches In Diameter | Brand: Monster K9 Dog Toys | Toy Style: Throwing | Features: Treat Dispensing, Made of FDA Approved Food-Grade Rubber | Dogs: Medium To Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • Highly durable construction 
  • Safe for aggressive chewers
  • Ball design allows for extra bounce and spring after being thrown

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not suited for smaller dogs

For some dogs and their owners, there’s no better way to play than by tossing the old ball around. Monster K9 Toys Ultra-Durable Dog Ball is a great ball that both owners and pups alike will love! 

Made from FDA-approved food-grade rubber, this ball features a “bumpy” design that allows it to bounce and dart in random ways upon hitting the ground, providing dogs with a thrill of unpredictability and extra play and exercise during the chase! 

It also features a hole for treat dispensing, adding to your dog’s heightened enjoyment.

The name claims to be “Ultra-Durable”, and the material certainly matches that description. This toy is made to stand up to even the most aggressive of chewers and the company backs that up with a lifetime replacement warranty.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

5. Best Teeth Cleaning Toy: ZHEBU Dog Chew Toy

 Product Ratings

Price 5/5
Quality 4/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Fun Factor3/5

Size: 5.9 Inches Long, 1.9 Inches Wide | Brand: ZHEBU | Toy Style: Biting, Gnawing | Features: Toothpaste Dispensing, Teeth Cleaning | Dogs: Small and Medium Breeds 

What We Liked

  • Varied height and size bumps to help clean teeth
  • The middle of the toy is designed with a slit to thoroughly clean teeth 
  • There are small wells on each end to fill with doggie toothpaste to help clean their teeth even more
  • Great for puppies

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not suited for larger dogs and aggressive chewers
  • It’s a little on the big side for extra small breeds
  • Manufacturer does suggest a daily time limit for the toy

Oral care is incredibly important in keeping dogs healthy, and this is a toy that goes above and beyond to help keep dogs’ teeth and gums clean and in top shape! Made specifically with oral care and maintenance in mind, this toy from ZHEBU features a design specifically for cleaning teeth and gums. 

As well as physically cleaning teeth, each end of the toy also features a small well that can be filled with a treat, or more importantly, toothpaste that will help do even more to promote great oral health in your dog. 

The middle of the toy features a slit designed to clean teeth on multiple sides at once as your dog bites and chews on the toy.

It’s also a great toy for teething puppies, keeping their teeth clean and healthy during the growth process.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON

6. Best Flying Disc Toy: KONG – Flyer – Durable Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy

 Product Ratings

Price 4/5
Quality 5/5
Effectiveness 5/5
Fun Factor4/5

Sizes: Small (7 Inches Diameter) Large (9 Inches Diameter) | Brand: KONG | Toy Style: Throwing Disc | Features: Made of FDA Approved Food-Grade Rubber | Dogs: Medium To Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • Soft but durable natural rubber 
  • Superb for catch and fetch with Fido
  • For larger dogs from 30 to 65 pounds

What We Didn’t Like

  • Color could be brighter to improve visibility

If you have an energetic breed who loves nothing more than playing catch and fetch, why not add a new dimension to playtime with this rubber flying disc from Kong?

When you’re shopping for indestructible dog toys, you’ll immediately notice the dominance of Kong, a brand catering to the needs of large and powerful dogs with their high-grade toys. Kong gear isn’t cheap, but when you factor in the long lifespan you can expect, it makes a sound investment for your fur baby.

Not only is this rubber built to withstand plenty of sustained punishment, but it’s also soft enough not to hurt your pup when he’s playing.

This iteration is designed for dogs weighing between 30 and 65 pounds. If that doesn’t make the right fit, there is also a smaller version of this disc available.

A few customers complain about the dull color, which makes the disc tough to find if it gets lost in the undergrowth when you’re playing with Rover. This minor gripe aside, user testimony is mainly positive.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON SEE PRICE ON CHEWY

7. Best Small Breed Toy: Nylabone X-Shaped Dog Bone

 Product Ratings

Price 5/5
Quality 5/5
Effectiveness 4/5
Fun Factor4/5

Sizes: Small (3.75″ long x 1.5 ” wide x 0.75″ high) Large (5.75″ long x 2 ” wide x 1.25″ high) | Brand: Nylabone | Toy Style: Throwing, Pulling | Features: Made of FDA Approved Food-Grade Rubber | Dogs: Small To Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • Comes in 3 flavors 
  • Great for small and extra small breeds
  • Larger size for bigger breeds

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not suitable for aggressive chewers

Sometimes it feels like finding toys for smaller breeds can be a real task, but this Nylabone X-Shaped Dog Bone will be sure to please any dog, regardless of size! There is a small and a large option for dogs of all sizes!

Sold in three different long-lasting flavors (Beef, Beef and Cheese, and Bacon), this toy will be sure to provide hours of enjoyment for your dog! This toy can be thrown or used as a pull toy.

With a multi-textured surface, this toy is also great at helping clean teeth and improve gum health in dogs while being played with!

This toy also has a version specifically for teething puppies that is soft and flexible and designed to help ease pain during the teething process while teaching non-destructive chewing habits.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON SEE PRICE ON CHEWY

8. Best All-Natural Toy: White Tail Naturals Huge Water Buffalo Bully Horn

 Product Ratings

Price 4/5
Quality 5/5
Effectiveness 4/5
Fun Factor3/5

Sizes: XL (8.35 x 8.27 x 2.56 inches; 10.05 Ounces Package Dimensions) 3XL (10.43 x 8.58 x 2.24 inches; 13.44 Ounces Package Dimensions | Brand: White Tail Naturals | Toy Style: Throwing, Gnawing | Features: Sourced From 100% Free Range Buffalo | Dogs: Small To Large Breeds 

What We Liked

  • All-natural treat laden with protein but low in fat
  • Organic and grain-free with no added preservatives or additive
  • Ideal for all life stages and breeds

What We Didn’t Like

  • A few owners claim this treat is prone to splintering

Have you been searching for a natural dog toy? If so, there’s every chance you’ve burned through a number of useless options. Is this water buffalo horn worth your time or a waste of money?

For any dog struggling with weight management, these treats are tailor-made. Packed with protein but super low in fat, you’ll give your pup everything he needs and nothing he doesn’t. You won’t get any nasty fillers, additives, or artificial colorings thrown in either.

Grain-free and totally organic, these bully horns make a neat fit for any pet owner concerned about chemicals and preferring an all-natural route to dog toys.

The strength of this horn is such that even more feisty pooches should meet their match. As with all these indestructible dog toys, it makes sense to monitor your dog the first few times he uses it. You can then quickly determine whether or not he’s likely to splinter pieces off or not.

SEE PRICE ON AMAZON SEE PRICE ON CHEWY

Comparison Chart

ProductsBest OverallBest ForPullingBest For FetchingBest BallBest For Teeth CleaningBest Flying DiscBest Small BreedBest All Natural
Overall Rating5/54/54/54/54/54/54/53.75/4
Price5/53/55/53/55/54/55/54/5
Quality5/55/54/55/54/55/55/55/5
Effectiveness5/55/55/55/55/55/54/54/5
Fun Factor4/55/55/54/53/54/54/53/5

The Winner

In the end, the KONG Extreme Dog Toy was the toy that we got the best bang for our buck from. This treat-dispensing toy provides hours of fun and exercise for both dogs and owners alike, is incredibly durable and ready to stand up to the test, and it comes in a wide array of sizes for dogs of all sizes. 

How to Choose the Best Indestructible Dog Toys For Your Dog

Cute dog holding chew toy
Finding the right indestructible dog toy for your dog falls down to their specific likes, needs, and chewing capacity.

Know How Your Dog Likes to Play

Some dogs like to fetch. Others like to play tug-of-war. Some like to chase the ball. To keep them engaged, cater to how your dog likes to play. The more they play, the healthier they will be because of it, and choosing a toy that they won’t want to put down will keep you and your dog playing together for years to come.

Pick a Toy That’s the Proper Size for Your Dog

One toy does not fit all. If you have a smaller breed of dog, some of the toys on this list may be far too big for your dog. Many of them come in different sizes to fit most sizes, but make sure to buy a toy that won’t be too big or too small for your dog, or else they may not want to play with it. 

Consider How Aggressive Your Dog Plays

Some dogs like to really go to town on their toys with aggressive biting and gnawing. 

As we’ve said, no toy is truly indestructible, and if your dog is an aggressive chewer, then you’ll definitely want to look into the highest quality toys, and even ones with replacement warranties in the event that your dog manages to chew its way through them. 

READ MORE: The Best Chew Toys for Pit Bulls. Pit Bulls are some of the heaviest chewing breeds out there. We tested the top chew toys for Pits in a complete guide!

Honorable Mentions

Here’s a brief look at the indestructible chew toy options that didn’t make our list, but are still worth a look.

1. M.C. Works Pineapple Dog Chew – Considered for Best Teeth Cleaning Toy

This unique pineapple chew toy is a great choice for teeth cleaning with its design featuring holes to promote clean teeth and healthy gums. It can be played in a number of ways, but in the end, we chose the ZHEBU Dog Chew Toy because it can deliver toothpaste to your pooch in a more direct manner.

2. Buck Bone Organic Elk’s Antler – Considered for Best All Natural Toy

This all-natural elk antler was a great entry among our all-natural toys and even comes in a variety of sizes and pack options. 

Like the White Tail Naturals Huge Water Buffalo Bully Horn, it’s a very healthy treat for your dog, high in protein and low in fat, but we ultimately went with the Buffalo horn due to an odor that will resonate from the elk antler after a short period.

3. Jolly Pets Rope And Ball Dog Toy – Considered for Best Ball

This ball with an attached rope is a great ball toy that comes in a wide variety of sizes and colors. It’s great for fetching and pulling, but we found our dogs seemed to enjoy the Ultra-Durable Dog Ball a little more because of the unpredictability and added chase it provided after being thrown.

4. Pet Qwerks BarkBone Stick – Considered for Best Fetch Toy

The Pet Qwerks BarkBone Stick is a great fetch toy that will provide plenty of its own hours of fun, and is made with human-grade peanut butter to keep your dog satisfied while chewing. 

It was narrowly edged out by the Wingpet Indestructible Dog Chew Toy by being easier to throw, paving the way for us to provide more exercise for our dogs.

5. Benebone Durable Wishbone Dog Chew – Considered for Best Pull Toy

The Benebone Durable Wishbone Dog Chew is a great way to engage your dog in a battle of tug-o-war. Available in 3 flavors (Bacon, Chicken, and Peanut), this toy will provide hours of chewing fun for your pup.

The Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Dog Pull Toy separates itself from others by providing a better grip to tug with and not being a product meant to degrade and be ingested over time.

6. West Paw Zogoflex Zisc Dog Frisbee – Considered for Best Flying Disc Toy

Made of FDA-approved food-grade rubber, West Paw’s Zogoflex Zisc Dog Frisbee is a great flying disc. It comes in two sizes, 6.5 and 8.5 inches, and is highly durable.

We prefer the KONG – Flyer – Durable Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy because it is slightly larger and has a better grip, making it easier to throw to our dogs.

7. Clean Teeth Interactive Corn Toy – Considered for Best Teeth Cleaning Toy

The Clean Teeth Interactive Corn Toy is another great teeth-cleaning toy that comes with a squeaker (in larger sizes) and provides a great chewable surface for cleaning teeth. Because of the absence of toothpaste distribution, it ultimately fell below the ZHEBU Dog Chew Toy on our list.

8. West Paw Zogoflex Jive Ball – Considered for Best Ball

When it comes to the ball, West Paw’s Zogoflex Jive Ball kept it simple and didn’t attempt to reinvent the wheel. The plus side is that if you are looking for a water-safe toy that is floatable, this is it. 

But for us, the treat delivery and extra exercise opportunity provided by the Ultra-Durable Dog Ball made it just a little bit better than the Zogoflex Jive Ball.

5/5 - (5 votes)

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 5

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

BarkVa is reader supported. When you buy through a link on our site we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate, BarkVa earns from qualifying purchases.

Leave a Comment