The 16 Best Indestructible Dog Toys

Best-Indestructible-Dog-Toys

Dogs are easygoing animals and not exactly picky about what goes in their mouth.

From the TV remote to your new Nike or Adidas, it seems nothing is safe, not even your precious furniture!

Nothing is safe, that is, until you consider the best indestructible dog toys.

Before we go any further, a quick note. Dogs have incredibly sharp teeth and can bite down with remarkable pressure. This being the case, no toy is literally indestructible. We say this not to disappoint you, but rather to keep your expectations reasonable.

Beyond this, you’ll also need to think about the size, breed, and temperament of your pooch.

If you’re still unsure what you’re looking for, focus on the following pointers when you’re hunting for a new treat for your hound.

  • Your dog’s personality: As well as the size of your pup, you should also factor in how your dog likes to play, whether or not he enjoys playing in the water, if he enjoys chasing and fetching – what dog doesn’t, right? – since all these factors will dictate the most suitable type of toy. Don’t rush this part of your buying decision or you’re highly likely to get it wrong
  • Material: All the toys we review are made from robust, safe, and non-toxic material. If your dog tends to bite hard, avoid those toys with a reputation for splintering
  • Design and color: Any sharp edges are a recipe for disaster. Opt for lighter colored toys so you can more easily see when they pick up some dirt
  • Natural and organic options: If you’re an eco-conscious shopper, you’re spoiled for choice with natural and all-organic options
  • Price/performance ratio: We typically steer you toward great value products, but in the case of dog toys for pups that bite lots, you should dig deeper. A cheap dog toy is likely to let you down and could even end up breaking and injuring your furball

Now, with those basics sketched in, it’s time for the main event. We’ve assembled a cross-section of the most durable toys you can find to keep even the most bite-prone dog in check.

BarkVA is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

I. The 16 Best Indestructible Dog Toys

1. Our #1 Pick: Kong Extreme Dog Toy

KONG-Extreme-Dog-Toy-Toughest-Natural-Rubber,-Black-Fun-to-Chew,-Chase-and-Fetch

The Kong brand has a wide variety of great dog toys, but we’re limiting ourselves to just one today in the form of this Extreme toy.

Sized from small through XXL, you should easily find something strong enough for the most aggressive canine chewers. This Extreme model is finished in black rubber and is specifically designed for power chewers.

It’s not just giving your pup’s jaws and teeth a workout where this toy excels, though. With Extreme, your dog will stay stimulated not bored. He can also sharpen his digging and hiding skills while the toy can even help if he’s suffering from separation anxiety.

Now, to save repeating ourselves, you’ll find user reviews from some disgruntled pet owners suggesting that their hound destroyed this toy just like most of the others we review. You know your dog’s behavior better than anyone so bear this in mind: if he wrecks every other toy he touches, chances are he’ll tear his way through this as well.

When your furball is done playing, just slip this toy in the dishwasher and you’re good to go.

Things We Like:

  • Multipurpose toy your pooch will love chewing, chasing, and fetching
  • Dishwasher-friendly so no hassle with clean-up
  • Backed by vets worldwide as a healthy and safe dog toy

Things We Dislike:

  • The fiercest dogs might chew their way through eventually!

2. Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Dog Pull Toy

Goughnuts-Virtually-Indestructible-Dog-Pull-Toy

If you have a larger breed and your dog is also an aggressive chewer, you may be tearing your hair out in the search for an indestructible dog toy. The Goughnuts Store is stuffed with items like this dog pull toy that should keep power chewers from destroying it without causing any damage to their teeth.

The toy is made from food-grade rubber that’s approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), so you have no health or safety concerns here.

The vast bulk of user testimony concerning this toy is positive. We found some isolated complaints about dogs breaking the toy, but this is almost inevitable with the power in the jaws of some breeds. There really is no such thing as a completely indestructible dog toy, but this is the next best thing.

Made in the USA by a family-run company, you can buy with complete confidence and inject some fun into Fido’s playtime without worrying about him chewing it into tiny pieces.

If you’re still in any doubt, this toy comes guaranteed for life by the manufacturer, meaning you have literally nothing to lose.

Things We Like

  • Great for larger breeds
  • Made from FDA food-grade rubber
  • Guaranteed for life

Things We Dislike

  • Some reported breakage

3. Ultra-Durable Chew Toy by Monster K9 Dog Toys Store

Ultra-Durable-Chew-Toy-Lifetime-Replacement-Guarantee

The Monster K9 Dog Toys Store is crammed with goodies to liven up the lives of dogs and owners the world over. How does this super-rugged chew toy stand up, then?

The natural rubber ring should stand up to the biting and chewing of more aggressive dogs, although user reviews suggest this 12oz toy is better-suited for smaller and medium breeds. Owners of large breeds have reported their dogs breaking off pieces of the toy, and in some cases eating the pieces. As with all toys in this vertical, you should examine the manufacturer’s marketing claims with caution and focus more fully on what real users report back after using these toys.

Backed by a lifetime replacement guarantee, you can buy with total confidence and give your pup some playtime fun he shouldn’t destroy in an instant.

Whether you’re playing fetch and catch or tug of war, you and your furball should get endless mileage from this toy. You may find your dog simply likes to skulk off with the ring and give his teeth and gums a workout while he curls up on his bed.

For owners of aggressive chewers, this toy is one of the best options up for grabs.

Things We Like

  • Ideal for aggressive chewers
  • Completely non-toxic materials
  • Lifetime replacement guarantee

Things We Dislike

  • Not great for larger breeds

4. Benebone Durable Wishbone Dog Chew

Benebone-Real-Bacon-Durable-Wishbone-Dog-Chew-Toy-for-Aggressive-Chewers

Benebone serves up a highly durable and dog-friendly wishbone chew. What do you get for your money, then?

Firstly, choose from real chicken, real bacon, or real peanut flavor. This is the bacon iteration of the chew and it should drive your furball wild.

The curved nature of this chew is intelligently designed, enabling your dog to pick it up easily with his paws. Since your dog doesn’t have thumbs, the wishbone shape will sit neatly when he’s chewing away at it without constantly slipping from his grasp.

A common theme throughout user reviews is the strength of the customer service department. Although a few customers ran into issues with this toy breaking, they report having their problem handled efficiently and helpfully.

Made in the USA by dog lovers, this is one of the best indestructible dog toys you’ll find, and it’s pretty reasonably priced, too.

Things We Like

  • Multiple sizes and flavors
  • Easy for your pooch to pick up
  • Made in the USA

Things We Dislike

  • Power chewers might damage this chew

5. Kong Extreme Ball

KONG-Extreme-Ball-Durable-Rubber-Dog-Toy-for-Power-Chewers

Next up is another entry from industry heavyweight Kong. The Extreme Ball is one of the most enduringly popular indestructible dog toys, with a large proportion of the abundant user reviews highly praiseworthy.

Ideal for medium and large breeds, especially those dogs prone to aggressively chewing, you’ll give your dog’s teeth and gums a workout while allowing him to chew to his heart’s content, and you shouldn’t end up with a ball in bits and pieces after a few days either.

The ball is remarkably bouncy, so makes for an entertaining game with an energetic dog. This thing will drive him crazy!

Puncture-resistant, you can safely leave your larger power chewer unattended for extended periods with this toy and he should never work his way through it.

The only blowback we unearthed concerning this modern classic dog toy centers on the difficulty of cramming treats inside this thing. Aside from this small niggle, you’re getting one of the best and most durable toys in this class.

Things We Like

  • For medium to large power chewers
  • Great bounce for intense exercise
  • Satisfaction guarantee

Things We Dislike

  • Difficult to stuff ball with treats

6. West Paw Hurley Dog Toy

West-Paw-Zogoflex-Hurley-Dog-Bone-Chew-Toy-Floatable-Pet-Toys-for-Aggressive-Chewers

West Paw make some rock-solid pet toys capable of keeping your mutt occupied for hours. What’s the deal with this floating bone, then?

If you frequently head down to the water with your pup, why not liven up his outing with this safe and dishwasher-friendly bone?

The Hurley is the most rugged of the wide line of toys. Suitable for even more aggressive breeds, choose from 3 sizes to suit.

Designed in tandem with Zogoflex, these chews are FDA-compliant so you can give them to your pups with a clear conscience.

When your dog has finally decimated this chew, you can send it back to the manufacturer for recycling. So, do your part for the environment while also giving your mutt a treat: what’s not to love?

Things We Like:

  • Floating bone ideal for water play
  • A far safer alternative to your dog gnawing on sticks
  • Trio of sizes to suit most breeds

Things We Dislike:

  • A few complaints about lifespan from disgruntled users

7. White Tail Naturals Water Buffalo Bully Horn

White-Tail-Naturals-Huge-Water-Buffalo-Bully-Horn-(1Pack)-(XXXL,-XXL-and-Extra-Large)-Giant-All-Natural-Dog-Chew-and-Training-Treat

Have you been searching for a natural dog toy? If so, there’s every chance you’ve burned through a number of useless options. Is this water buffalo horn worth your time or a waste of money?

For any dogs struggling with weight management, these treats are tailor-made. Packed with protein but super-low in fat, you’ll give your pup everything he needs and nothing he doesn’t. You won’t get any nasty fillers, additives, or artificial colorings thrown in either.

Grain-free and totally organic, these bully horns make a neat fit for any pet owners concerned about chemicals and preferring an all-natural route to dog toys.

The strength of this horn is such that even more feisty pooches should meet their match. As with all these indestructible dog toys, it makes sense to monitor your dog the first few times he uses it. You can then quickly determine whether or not he’s likely to splinter pieces off or not.

Things We Like:

  • All-natural treat laden with protein but low in fat
  • Organic and grain-free with no added preservatives or additives
  • Ideal for all life stages and breeds

Things We Dislike:

  • A few owners claim this treat is prone to splintering

8. Pet Qwerks BarkBone Stick

Pet-Qwerks-BarkBone-Stick-For-Aggressive-Chewers

Coming in mint or peanut butter flavor, what makes this BarkBone stick from Pet Qwerks stand out?

Shaped just like a regular bone, give your hound a taste of the wild and a dental-friendly treat capable of scouring away plaque and minimizing the chance of your pup needing cavities.

Non-edible, your dog can chew away while stimulating and massaging his gums.

While we could unearth no complaints about this toy being damaged by dogs, a few unhappy owners stated that their dog’s gums started to bleed after they used this bone. These risks apply to all sharp and bone-like objects, so we don’t feel this is a particular slight on this stick.

If your mutt routinely shreds and destroys seemingly unbreakable toys, unleash him on this bad boy!

Things We Like:

  • Stick shaped just like a real bone
  • Bone is non-edible so serves to massage your pup’s gums while scraping plaque from his teeth
  • Super-simple for your dog to grasp and hold

Things We Dislike:

  • Several owners suggest their dog experienced bleeding gums using this bone

9. West Paw Zogoflex Jive Ball

West-Paw-Zogoflex-Jive-Ball-Dog-Chew-Toy

West Paw is a pet specialist, and the Jive Ball is made in tandem with Zogoflex, so what do you get with this toy?

Firstly, this ball works equally well indoors or outside in the yard. A few customers complain about the heavyweight nature of the ball, while the manufacturer claims it’s extremely light. It weighs 0.55 pounds, so only you know whether that’s suitable for your fur baby.

The toy floats, making it a great companion if you head to the beach with your dog, or if you frequently go for walks by the water.

As an added bonus, you can slip this toy in the top rack of the dishwasher for hands-free cleaning, too.

Made from a latex-free material that’s fully FDA-compliant and made here in the United States, you’re getting a first class dog toy from two specialist manufacturers, giving you everything you need and nothing you don’t.

Things We Like

  • Perfect for indoor or outdoor play
  • Non-toxic and latex-free
  • Floatable for water play

Things We Dislike

  • Heavier than most balls

10. Nylabone Store Dinosaur Chew Toy

3-Pack-Nylabone-Durable-Dental-Dinosaur-Chew-Toy

As we near the end of our search for the best indestructible dog toys, we have a dinosaur-themed offering from the Nylabone Store.

Each pack contains 3 oversized dinosaur toys measuring up at 7.9 x 5.8 x 4.3 inches. The toys weigh 14oz, so they are reasonably heavyweight. You get a T-Rex, a Stegosaurus, and a Brontosaurus in each pack. Some users report not receiving different types of dinosaur, so check the contents of your package closely on arrival.

Designed expressly for powerful chewers weighing up to 50 pounds, if this sounds like a neat match for your furball, you’ll be giving your dog more than just a dose of entertainment.

These toys are chicken flavored and appetizing for canines. You’ll be catering to your dog’s primal urge to chew, and you’ll also be ensuring that plaque and tartar buildup on his teeth is minimized. Nubs and bristle on the toy raise when your dog chews to give him a full dental workout while keeping his dental hygiene uppermost.

Lifespan is less impressive than reported on many competing indestructible dog toys, so if you’re shopping with durability as a priority, we would recommend one of the alternative toys we review today.

Things We Like

  • Playful dinosaur shapes
  • Chicken flavored chew toys
  • Promotes great dental hygiene

Things We Dislike

  • Reasonably short lifespan

11. Kong Flyer Durable Rubber Flying Disc

KONG-Flyer-Durable-Rubber-Flying-Disc-Dog-Toy

If you have an energetic breed who loves nothing more than playing catch and fetch, why not add a new dimension to playtime with this rubber flying disc from Kong?

When you’re shopping for indestructible dog toys, you’ll immediately notice the dominance of Kong, a brand catering for the needs of large and powerful dogs with their high-grade toys. Now, Kong gear isn’t cheap, but when you factor in the lengthy lifespan you can expect, it makes a sound investment for your fur baby.

Not only is this rubber built to withstand plenty of sustained punishment, but it’s also soft enough not to hurt your pup when he’s playing.

This iteration is designed for dogs weighing between 30 and 65 pounds. If that doesn’t make the right fit, there is also a smaller version of this disc available.

A few customers complain about the dull color that makes the disc tough to find if it gets lost in the undergrowth when you’re playing with Rover. This minor gripe set aside, user testimony is mainly positive.

Things We Like

  • Soft but durable natural rubber
  • Superb for catch and fetch with Fido
  • For larger dogs from 30 to 65 pounds

Things We Dislike

  • Color could be brighter to improve visibility

12. Jolly Pets Rope and Ball Dog Toy

Jolly-Pets-Romp-n-Roll-Rope-and-Ball-Dog-Toy

If you’re looking for a pocket-friendly and highly durable dog toy that’s currently available at a discount, act quickly and grab a bargain from Jolly Pets in the form of this rope and ball dog toy.

Choose from a half-dozen bright colors you can easily spot if the toy goes astray. You’ll then need to opt for a pack of 1, 2, or 3 toys to suit. The final choice is between the 3 available sizes. This toy is the Large, measuring 8 inches across. Weighing just over 1 pound, this is a fairly heavy toy so works best with larger breeds.

Ideal for playing tug or chase, this floatable toy also works well in the water.

If you’re looking for one of the best indestructible dog toys on the market and you don’t mind digging a little deeper, we can’t recommend this model highly enough.

Things We Like

  • Wide choice of vibrant colors
  • For tug, chase, and swimming play
  • Made in the USA

Things We Dislike

  • Quite heavy

13. Buck Bone Organic Elk’s Antler

Buck-Bone-Organics-Elk-Antlers-for-Dogs,-Premium-Grade-A-Elk-Naturally-Sourced-from-Montana

Next up we have an organic elk’s antler from Buck Bone that comes in a nifty resealable pouch so you can contain the smell when it’s not in use. We point this out since a handful of disgruntled users complained about the odor of this antler.

The all-natural flavor will remind your dog of life in the wild without forcing him to endure any hardship.

Choose from a variety of pack sizes to suit the number of dogs you have and your budget. If you’re hoping to kiss goodbye to chemicals and give your dog a natural and completely organic toy that also happens to be nigh-indestructible, you can’t go wrong here.

Things We Like:

  • Choose from a range of pack sizes to suit
  • All-natural to give your hound a taste of the wild
  • Resealable pouch bundled to keep antler fresh

Things We Dislike:

  • Some users complain of a smell developing after a few days

14. Goughnuts Original Medium Dog Chew

Goughnuts-Original-Medium-Dog-Chew-Toy-Ring-for-Aggressive-Chewers-from-30-70-Pounds

Goughnuts produce a range of indestructible dog toys capable of keeping dogs from 10 pounds to over 100 pounds happy, stimulated, and entertained.

These toys come in a dazzling array of sizes and strengths to suit the breed and temperament of dogs you have at home.

As with all these toys designed to withstand serious punishment, you might find your dog chews through this eventually. If you’ve previously disappointed by toys with a poor lifespan, you’ll appreciate the lifetime warranty you get with this toy.

Things We Like:

  • Multiple grades available to suit the aggression of your dog
  • Toys available for dogs from 10 to 100+ pounds
  • Lifetime warranty for complete peace of mind

Things We Dislike:

  • Some dogs might manage to chew off parts of this toy

15. M.C. Works Pineapple Dog Chew

M.C.works-Pineapple-Dog-Chew-Toys-for-Aggressive-Chewer

As we edge to the end of our indestructible dog toy reviews, a striking and heavyweight pineapple that should keep even the most aggressive biters happy all day long.

Whether you want to add another layer to your hound’s dental hygiene routine, you need to keep him occupied while you’re at work, or you just want to remind him of life in the wild, investing in this durable toy will make your dog remarkably happy.

Made by a family-owned and family-run company in the USA, you can buy with complete confidence. Not only is this one of the most robust toys you can find, it’s also warrantied for life so what are you waiting for?

Things We Like:

  • Highly versatile toy that promotes chewing while also acting as a stress-reliever for your furball
  • Large and bulky chew that should withstand some serious punishment
  • Ongoing replacement offer for life of product

Things We Dislike:

  • Not cut out for really aggressive chewers

16. West Paw Zogoflex Tuck Tree Interactive Dog Chew

West-Paw-Zogoflex-Tux-Treat-Dispensing-Dog-Chew-Toy

To round out, we have another Zogoflex gem from West Paw, but what differentiates this toy from the pack?

Well, unlike the other toys we review, this also serves double duty as a treat dispenser. Load in your pooch’s favorite snacks and watch as he plays to get his reward.

Once you’re done, all you need to do is pop this toy in the dishwasher to keep hygiene uppermost.

Choose from a bewildering range of colors schemes to keep your dog content and to ensure his teeth remain at their very best.

Things We Like:

  • Comes in an impressive array of colorways
  • Stimulating and interactive toy to keep your dog mentally engaged
  • Non-toxic, dishwasher-friendly and completely recyclable

Things We Dislike:

  • Opening for the treat is just too shallow

OK, just before we round out for the day, we’ve put together some answers to the most frequently asked questions about unbreakable dog toys.

II. FAQs

Indestructible-Dog-Toys

1) Are any dog toys really indestructible?

There are too many variables to offer a definitive answer. As we mentioned right at the start, you should be wary of toys marketed as unbreakable due to the mechanics of a dog’s teeth and biting power. The best you can hope for is a toy that gives you a reasonable lifespan for the price. All the toys we review above should last for years.

2) Do very durable dog toys come with any drawbacks?

They sure do. No product is perfect. These super-rugged toys might be too heavy for some dogs. Depending on how your dog bites, he could end up destroying the toy quicker than you think.

3) Is it not best to have dog toys made from soft material?

No. Soft toys made from fabric might be easy on your dog’s mouth, but they’re not long-lasting.

4) Is it worth paying more for a great indestructible dog toy?

With these products, we would have to say it’s a wise idea to spend out on a decent model and you should be rewarded with a toy that’s built to stay the distance. We’ve included a worthwhile budget pick if you’re tight for cash but not prepared to compromise on quality.

5) What’s the single most indestructible dog toy on the market?

In our opinion, nothing comes close to the Kong Extreme dog toy. Not only is this particular toy practically unbreakable, but the manufacturer also produces a deep bench of rugged toys and supplies to keep your dog happy year-round even if he usually leaves his new toys in tatters within minutes.


III. Conclusion

We trust by now you have a solid understanding of the most durable and stimulating toys to keep your dog’s teeth and gums on point while also keeping him occupied and stimulated.

If you frequently head down to the water with your hound, you can find plenty of suitable floating toys. The same applies if you want toys designed for your dog to chase and fetch. Throw in interactive dog toys and organic products that remind them of life in the wild, you have no shortage of options.

Stick with any of the indestructible dog toys we review and you’re in totally safe hands. How about if you spot a toy not on our list? No problem. All you need to do is study our brief buying guide above and you should have no issue picking up an appropriate toy without too much time or trouble.

Bookmark BarkVA and be sure to head back soon.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases - at no cost to you, allowing us to continue our work.

Leave a Comment