As all pet owners know, dogs normally hate wearing anything. From harnesses, and vibrating collars, to coats, and boots, you’ll typically struggle when introducing your dog to anything new.
Here at BarkVa, we understand this struggle and are here to help.
We are quite familiar with this process and at one point or another, every single one of our pups has had their turn wearing at least one of these devices.
Our dog’s experience with each of these products made an excellent resource in helping us create this list of the best dog cones and e-collars out there.
After many hours of research, we chose the best 13 different E-collars/dog cones our pups have worn and wrote about their experience with each one.
We ended up with 6 top picks and 7 honorable mentions.
Our Top Picks
| Product | Details | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Best Overall: Supet Dog Cone | The Supet dog cone is a variant of the iconic cone of shame that dog owners tend to love or hate (and most dogs hate). Crafted with high-quality materials and an excellent design, we would highly recommend checking this one out! | Check Price |
 |
Best Budget Pick: Care 4U Dog Cone Collars | Looking for e-cones on a budget? If so, the Care 4U Dog Cone is a perfect choice for you! It comes with 5 different-sized cones and is known to be quite reliable. | Check Price |
 |
Best For Small Dogs: Vivifying Store Adjustable Pet Cone | This Cone is a great fit for all small dogs and puppies. Whether you want to keep your dog from licking an open wound or to keep it protected from itself after surgery, this multipurpose and highly adjustable cone is perfect for the job! | Check Price |
 |
Best For Big Dogs: ZenPet Recovery Cone E-Collar | Whatever your requirements are, this soft collar will keep your dog comfortable without causing the discomfort a plastic collar can induce. It’s also great for larger dogs. | Check Price |
 |
Most Durable Option: Remedy And Recovery E-Collar | Remedy and Recovery delivers a classic cone design that will keep your pet safe and sound! Being so resilient and affordable, this cone was one we had to have on our list! | Check Price |
 |
Most Comfortable Pick: Think ECO Organic Cotton Pet Recovery Cone Collar | As far as materials go, this product is the best of the best. Made with organic fabric and cotton, this cone is extremely soft. It is an absolute favorite of our dogs! | Check Price |
How We Tested Each Dog Cone
We wanted to make sure that each product was tested accurately and fairly for this experiment.
We decided to identify the 5 most vital qualities in an ideal dog cone/e-collar and then analyze each product accordingly to compare the results.
Here’s what we decided on:
- Size
- Cost
- Materials
- Reliability
- Value
Our search led us to many different brands, each offering different materials and quality. We also made sure to note the prices and value for each product.
ZenPet came up quite a lot in our research. Since their founding in 2016, they have made quite the name for themselves in a relatively short amount of time!
Loved and trusted by many dog owners, we knew this brand would make a great fit for our list.
We made sure to look out for durable and high-quality dog cones readily available at reasonable prices.
This led us to Fezep, a well-known brand for its affordable dog cones and artificial grass play rugs, this a brand that is definitely worth checking out!
Think ECO was another brand that came up a lot in our research.
They’re quite established in this industry and trusted by millions of dog owners all over the world for their thoughtful, sustainable, and organic products!
We also took opinions from the dog owner community online, zeroing in on reviews and recommendations shared on popular shopping sites such as Chewy and Amazon.
This information was very helpful for formulating our list.
We settled on 13 different highly-rated dog cones we have tried in the past with our pups, recording how they liked each cone throughout their use of it as well as how well it did the job.
We ended up with 6 top choices and 7 honorable mentions to follow.
Read our related article on Why Dogs Lick Wounds and pus, and why it’s important that you prevent them from doing so!
Top 6 Best E-Collars and Cones for Dogs
1. Best Overall: Supet Dog Cone
Product Ratings
| Size | 5/5 |
| Cost | 4.7/5 |
| Materials | 4.3/5 |
| Reliability | 4.7/5 |
| Value | 5/5 |
Type: Recovery Collar I Design: Cone I Main Material(s): High-Quality PVC Material I Best for: All Dogs I Price: $
What We Liked
- Broad spread of sizings
- Durable PVC build with soft edges
- Affordable
What We Didn’t Like
- Some reported issues with sizing
- Grain-free recipe can cause health troubles for some dogs
- Can make some dogs a bit gassy
Supet is a serious contender in this industry with good reason. Their products and brand are trusted by pet owners all over the world for the consistency and value they deliver.
They produce products for all pets but mainly dogs.
Cone Design
This dog cone was produced to have a waterproof and translucent design, with different size options for all types of canines.
It’s also designed with an extra soft fabric edge to ensure maximum comfort while your pup wears it.
This dog cone comes in 6 different sizes:
- Extra Small (9.8 – 11.2 inches)
- Small (11.5 – 12.7 inches)
- Medium (11.8 – 13.5 inches)
- Large (13.5 – 19 inches)
- Extra Large (19 – 20.5 inches)
- Extra Extra Large ( 20.5 + inches)
The unique button design on this product makes this cone easy to take on and take off.
There is a plastic clasp function on this collar that ensures once it goes on your pup, it will stay on.
Our Favorite Feature
What we loved the most about this product is the extra soft fabric edge, it was gentle on our dogs and made it easier for them to wear it.
Even our dogs with sensitive skin didn’t get irritated by this cone.
How Our Dogs Liked It
Our dogs seemed to like this one the most out of every other product on this list. It’s comfortable, soft, easy to use, and never came off after we put it on.
It also prevented all our dogs from being able to lick their hot spots, no matter how much they tried!
Like any cone, they were definitely uncomfortable with having it on but after about a week they seemed to be used to it.
Usually, when we first put a cone on our dogs, they end up spending all their time trying to take it off, but that wasn’t the case with this one!
What Other Customers Had to Say
We found many dog owners who loved this product because of how durable it is and how well it stays on.
Many love how affordable the price ranges are for this cone and for how easy it is to use.
Although the majority of user reviews for this collar are overwhelmingly positive, we found some scattered complaints centered on sizing inaccuracies.
This minor issue aside, you will still be getting one of the best dog cones out there!
SEE PRICE ON AMAZON2. Best Budget Pick: Care 4U Dog Collars
Product Ratings
| Size | 5/5 |
| Cost | 4.6/5 |
| Materials | 3.7/5 |
| Reliability | 3.5/5 |
| Value | 4.7/5 |
Type: Recovery Collar I Design: Cone I Main Material(s): PVC Transparent Plastic I Best for: Small Dogs-Regular Sized Dogs I Price: $
What We Liked
- Each set comes with 5 sizes
- Ideal for wound-healing
- Lightweight and non-toxic build
What We Didn’t Like
- The largest cone is too short for some dogs
- Doesn’t last long
- Can be especially uncomfortable for some pups
The Care 4U Dog Cone comes in at a price you’ll love. This pack contains 5 assorted cones ideal for a variety of ages and dog breeds.
How is this Cone Designed?
This cone is made with high-grade plastic that contains no toxins.
It is also light which will prove quite useful for your dog as it recovers. A heavy cone can be distracting for some pups and interrupt the healing process.
There are many different circumstances that this cone that could come in handy, here are some ways that we used it:
- For postoperative protection
- To prevent licking
- During medical/dermatologic treatment
- For grooming purposes
The high-quality velcro closures on this cone make it convenient to adjust and easy for your dog to wear.
This cone also has a cotton flannel on the edge so as to not hurt or irritate your dog’s neck while they wear it.
Our Favorite Feature
Our favorite feature of this product was the variety of multiple sizes that come with each purchase.
We have a lot of dogs so being able to get 5 different cones ranging from small to large at such an affordable price, was an absolute steal!
How Our Dogs Liked It
Most of our dogs didn’t like this cone, but it did the job well so we weren’t complaining!
That being said, some of our dogs with longer snouts were able to reach over the edge of their cones and lick their hot spots.
With our smaller dogs, this cone worked great and they were still able to eat their food with it on which was a plus.
The lightness of this cone also made it easy for our pups to move around efficiently without weighing them down.
What Other Customers Had to Say
Many claim that this dog cone worked wonders for their dog and did the job perfectly.
A lot of satisfied customers claimed that this product came with a great value for the price.
Some, however, said that this cone didn’t do the job for their dogs with long snouts.
SEE PRICE ON AMAZON3. Best for Small Dogs: Vivifying Store Adjustable Pet Cone
Product Ratings
| Size | 3.5/5 |
| Cost | 4.5/5 |
| Materials | 5/5 |
| Reliability | 4/5 |
| Value | 3.7/5 |
Type: Recovery Collar I Design: Collar I Main Material(s): Lightweight PVC I Best for: Small Dogs I Price: $
What We Liked
- Fits puppies and small breeds
- Adjustable closures
- Available in 4 different colors
What We Didn’t Like
- Cone is quite short
- Not a good fit for dogs with tear stain problems
- Kibble not small enough for some dogs
It is especially important that puppies and small dogs have a high-quality recovery cone.
We want all pups to grow to their highest potential without any unnecessary setbacks due to licking incisions or hot spots.
Vivifying delivers a cone perfect for this purpose!
Collar Design
This lightweight PVC collar is a great fit for any puppy or small dog.
It’s made with soft, flannel rims that are gentle on your dog’s neck. There are also 3 different adjustable snap closures to help ensure a proper fit on your dog.
This dog cone comes in 4 different colors:
- Blue
- Green
- Pink
- Red
We liked that the plastic on this collar was easy to wipe and clean. This is a great collar that is durable and will last your pup a long while, it certainly did for ours!
Our Favorite Feature
Our favorite part of this dog cone is the materials that it’s made out of. We love the lightweight build and it had a very soft and smooth feel to it.
The soft padded inner liner in this product was such a thoughtful and considerate addition, which our dogs loved!
How Our Dogs Liked It
Our tiny dogs and puppies loved this cone, it was almost as if they didn’t realize it was on while they were wearing it.
It was so nice to see them sleep and eat comfortably without any issues.
While our pups didn’t seem to mind wearing this collar, it wasn’t always able to prevent them from getting to their paws.
It prevented them from getting to any other body part but the collar just wasn’t long enough to stop them from reaching their toes.
What Other Customers Had to Say
Reviews are generally positive for this dog food.
It’s a great product and sure to supply your young dog with the comfort and support of this highly-recommended dog collar.
Some felt that the sizing was limited and wished there was a wider range of choices.
For heavy chewers, we reviewed the Best Indestructible Dog Toys. Be sure to check those out!
SEE PRICE ON AMAZON4. Best for Big Dogs: ZenPet Recovery Cone E-Collar
Product Ratings
| Size | 4.7/5 |
| Cost | 3.5/5 |
| Materials | 4.7/5 |
| Reliability | 4.4/5 |
| Value | 3.9/5 |
Type: Recovery Cone I Design: E-Collar I Main Material(s): Polyester I Best for: Big Dogs I Price: $$
What We Liked
- Wide choice of sizes
- Adjustable velcro straps
- Veterinarian recommended
What We Didn’t Like
- Not the longest-lasting cone
- Can be hard to clean
- A bit expensive
Next in line is another soft e-collar that’s ideal for a wide variety of uses.
Whatever your requirements are, this soft collar made by ZenPet will keep your dog in check without causing him the discomfort a plastic collar can induce.
How is this Collar Designed?
This product was made to come in multiple different sizes, as well as being easy to adjust and use on all dogs.
It also comes with built-in windows to help your dogs maintain the view of their peripherals and sight with a collar on.
There is an adjustable velcro strap that helps keep the collar secure on your dog’s head.
We love this design because it forms around any dog’s collar and makes a snug fit. It is also extremely soft too!
Our Favorite Feature
We love this cone because not only do they have an extra-large option, but it actually fits properly on their head!
Most cones/e-collars we tried to get for our bigger dogs in the past were either way too short or way too small, so this one was great for that!
Amongst the extra-large mentioned earlier, there are 3 more different sizes:
- Small
- Medium
- Large
- X-Large
This collar is backed by vets and highly supported by dog owners all over the world, including us!
It was so nice to see our big dogs able to have a collar that didn’t make them uncomfortable but also stopped them from licking their hot spots.
How Our Dogs Liked It
Our big dogs didn’t necessarily like this cone, but that’s okay because it was at least bearable for them to wear.
They most definitely implemented the use of the window on the collar which was cool to observe!
By the end of their time using it, our dogs didn’t try to tear it up, which is actually a great compliment!
The adjustable velcro straps were a great help to us to ensure that the cone would stay until we took it off.
What Other Customers Had to Say
Most customers thought this product was beneficial for their dog’s recovery. It’s made with great material, comes in many different sizes, and is vet-recommended.
The only downside is the fact that this collar is a bit pricey.
SEE PRICE ON AMAZON SEE PRICE ON CHEWY5. Most Durable Option: Remedy and Recovery E-Collar
Product Ratings
| Size | 4/5 |
| Cost | 4/5 |
| Materials | 3.5/5 |
| Reliability | 4.5/5 |
| Value | 4.5/5 |
Type: Recovery Cone I Design: E-Collar I Main Material(s): Plastic I Best for: Small-Medium Size Dogs I Price: $$
What We Liked
- Lightweight
- Padded for extra comfort
- Clear, see through design
What We Didn’t Like
- Not suitable for dogs with long snouts
- Awkward to put on and remove
- Not all dogs able to eat with it on
The Remedy and Recovery E-Collar is a classic cone of shame design.
Made in an assortment of colors, this ultra-light PVC collar won’t weigh your dog down, even if he’s not too keen on his temporary accessory.
Collar Design
This collar is designed with transparent and see-through materials that ensure your dog won’t have any trouble seeing while it’s on.
It also comes with adjustable sizing and extra padding for a comfortable, snug fit.
It’s a light collar and is designed to help your dog on its journey to recovery.
Our Favorite Feature
This collar is highly durable and effective! It can be awkward to put on your pup, but once it’s on, it’s on.
There is no way any dog, even the most aggressive or clever will be able to get this collar off its head. Which was great for us!
This product is great for dogs who need a little extra help with:
- Treatment with hot spots
- Breaking the itch-scratching cycle
- Ending self-inflicted wounds
While this cone may be the classic cone of shame design, nonetheless it is an amazing product!
This cone helped us get through hard times and to this day it still works like the first day we got it.
How Our Dogs Liked It
We have two specific dogs who are masters at taking their cones off when we aren’t looking, and this was the only cone that has ever stopped them.
Which was impressive to us as we had never seen that happen before!
Our dogs didn’t seem to mind this cone either, it was light and comfortable for them to wear. They were able to eat and sleep peacefully with it on, which is a major plus!
What Other Customers Had to Say
Most user feedback concerning this collar is generally positive, but we found some scattered complaints about the difficulty of putting on and removing it.
Other than that, it is a reliable and brilliantly designed E-collar!
SEE PRICE ON AMAZON SEE PRICE ON CHEWY6. Most Comfortable Pick: Think ECO Organic Cotton Pet Recovery Cone Collar
Product Ratings
| Size | 3.8/5 |
| Cost | 3.5/5 |
| Materials | 5/5 |
| Reliability | 3.7/5 |
| Value | 4/5 |
Type: Recovery Cone I Design: Collar I Main Material(s): Organic Cotton I Best for: Small Dogs I Price: $$$
What We Liked
- Extremely comfortable
- Made with sustainable ingredients
- Comes in many fun designs
What We Didn’t Like
- Quite expensive
- Only useful for small dogs
- Can be hard to wash
If there was an award for the most comfortable dog collar, Think ECO would most definitely win it for this beautifully crafted dog cone.
Made for dogs with sensitive skin, this will certainly be a treat for them!
Collar Design
This collar is designed with organic fabric and comes in 5 different sizes.
The outer material of the cone is soft due to the cotton, but it also has a strong polyester filling. The adjustable strap and folding function on this collar make it efficient in its use.
There is a stable snap button on this collar which makes it easy and quick to put on and take off your dog. This collar is also lightweight.
Our Favorite Feature
This cone is extremely soft and an absolute favorite of all our tiny dogs. The cotton material gives it a smooth and satisfying feel, which our dogs fell in love with right away!
In what situation would my dog need to wear this collar?
- After neutering surgery
- As an alternative to a plastic collar
- Prevent irritation to hot spots
A dog’s skin is much thinner compared to that of human skin. Which makes it much more vulnerable to its environment and external stimuli.
So it’s vital that our dogs receive the best quality collars they can in their time of recovery!
How Our Dogs Liked It
As we mentioned earlier, this cone is a big favorite of our tiny dogs. Our pups acted as if they had a constant pillow/blanket attached to their head. They never looked more calm and peaceful in their life!
This cone worked great on those little dogs of ours but not so much our bigger pups.
It was just too flimsy to support such a big head and wasn’t able to stop them from getting to their hot spots.
What Other Customers Had to Say
There are many satisfied customers out there when it comes to this product, it is made with so much care and so much intent.
Truly one of the best collars we’ve ever come across, if only it wasn’t so expensive and had proper sizings for big dogs, too!
SEE PRICE ON AMAZONComparison Chart
| Products | Best Overall | Best Budget Pick | For Small Dogs | For Big Dogs | Most Durable Option |
| Size | 5/5 | 5/5 | 3.5/5 | 4.7/5 | 4/5 |
| Cost | 4.7/5 | 4.6/5 | 4.5/5 | 3.5/5 | 4/5 |
| Materials | 4.3/5 | 3.7/5 | 5/5 | 4.7/5 | 3.5/5 |
| Reliability | 4.7/5 | 3.5/5 | 4/5 | 4.4/5 | 4.5/5 |
| Value | 5/5 | 4.7/5 | 3.7/5 | 3.9/5 | 4.5/5 |
The Winner
Overall, our favorite choice off this list is the Supet Dog Cone.
This is a fantastic dog cone because it’s affordable, high quality, comfortable for dogs of all sizes, and sure to stop your dog from unintentionally delaying its recovery!
Honorable Mentions
Here’s a quick look at 7 other options that didn’t quite make our list of top picks.
1. The Original Comfy Cone – Considered for Best Overall
Though this is a great dog cone, it didn’t quite make our list because this brand had some product availability issues, as well as difficulties with quality control.
This cone is affordable, but when it came down to the final test, we had to choose Supet Dog Cone over this one because of its fantastic design and reliability!
2. Alfie Pet Noah Recovery Collar – Considered for Small Dogs
This product is so cute and will most definitely ensure some good laughs for any dog owners who put this on their dogs.
We love it and think it’s a great idea but it isn’t that practical compared to the other options on our list.
This product is great on its own, but it didn’t have all the qualities we were looking for.
The Vivifying Store Adjustable Pet Cone was favored because it is more suited and able to prevent dogs from licking their incisions or hot spots.
3. E-KOMG Dog Cone – Considered for Most Comfortable Pick
This is an excellent product because it is a great idea and is designed excellently!
We love the inflatable collar and the majority of our dogs found this to be very comfortable.
At times, this dog collar can be a bit inefficient and take up a lot of space.
We also had some issues with deflating, so that’s why we opted for the Think ECO Organic Cotton Pet Recovery Cone Collar instead.
4. Pet Baba Cone Collar – Considered for Small Dogs
This is a great dog collar and actually works great for most small dogs. We love how it was crafted and it had a stable, authentic feel to it.
This cone has some notable features such as:
- Sturdy, padded inner liner
- Button closure
- Lightweight PVC materials
We love how this product has some good color alternatives and was crafted specifically for smaller dogs.
However, it was harder to clean and less favored by our dogs than the Vivifying Store Adjustable Pet Cone.
5. KONG EZ Soft E-Collar – Considered for Our Most Comfortable Pick
While this is a high-quality dog cone, and our dogs loved this one almost as much as the Think ECO Organic Cotton Pet Recovery Cone Collar, they still favored it amongst most other options on the list. This is another one we highly recommend!
The one factor that gave #2 on our list an advantage was that it was more widely affordable and reliable compared to the former.
Other than that, the ingredients are amazing, the dogs love the taste, and it’s a great value for the price if you can afford it.
6. SunGrow Soft Cone Collar – Considered for Our Best Overall
This is a cute and finely-crafted dog cone. We think the design is amazing but it doesn’t quite help prevent licking as the Supet Dog Cone does.
On the other hand, it is easy to maintain and is comfortable for most dogs.
Made with high-quality ingredients and an excellent design, this is a cone we would still highly recommend checking out!
7. Felicey Adjustable Collar – Considered for Big Dogs
This is a great dog cone and works wonders for many, many pups.
However, it didn’t quite compare to the ZenPet Recovery Cone E-Collar because of the variety of sizings that it lacks.
We would recommend this product to owners of small-medium dogs as it seems those are the types of pups it works the best for.
It’s manufactured with high quality and is durable, reliable cone perfect for the majority of dogs out there!
