10 Best Bully Sticks for Dogs: All Natural treats for Big and small dogs

It’s no secret that dogs love to chew.

Bully Sticks taste good in the Snow!

As well as helping dog to relieve boredom while getting a taste of beef pizzle, dog chews can also encourage sound dental and gum hygiene in your furball.

One type of chew popular with dogs the world over is the bully stick, made from the penis of a bull.

Bully sticks are typically made of beef and contain few additives or chemicals.

Are they any good for your dog, though?

See below for related articles if your dog needs more than a snack. We have a complete breakdown of many different types of dog food:
15 Best Budget-Friendly Dog Foods
10 Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters
18 Best Dog Food with Grains
14 Best Dog Food for Weight Loss
10 Best High Fiber Dog Foods
15 Best Dog Food for Puppies

Are Best Bully Sticks Good for Dogs?

If you’ve been questioning whether these strange chews are any good for Fido, the answer is a resounding yes.

Firstly, bully sticks are all pretty easy for your dog to digest. The same doesn’t apply to all dog chews.

Beyond this, these chews are also loaded with protein, while typically quite low in fat and calories. With no chemicals or additives either, your dog is getting plenty of health benefits when you treat him to some bully sticks.

As a final bonus, bully sticks are also great for your dog’s teeth and gums.

How often can you give these chews to Rover, then?

Can I Give My Dog a Bully Stick Every Day?

If you have a dog with no weight issues, you could give him one bully stick a day with no problem. Don’t give him more than this, though.

Even if your pooch is struggling with weight management, you could still treat him to a daily bully stick. Just be certain to tweak his caloric intake to compensate, but discontinue this practice if he still seems hungry.

How Do I Choose a Bully Stick for My Dog?

If you’ve never looked for bully sticks before, how do you go about choosing the right ones for your dog?

Luckily, this is not the most complex buying decision you’ll face as a dog owner, so focus on the following pointers to get the most suitable chews:

  • Size of sticks: If bully sticks are too small, they present a choking hazard. If the sticks are too big, though, your dog will struggle to chew all the way through. For dogs weighing from 10 to 30 pounds, opt for 4-inch bully sticks. For dogs weighing from 30 to 50 pounds, 6-inch to 8-nch bully sticks are ideal. Use 10 to 14-inch bully sticks for dogs weighing from 50 to 100 pounds, and choose 20 to 24-inch chews if your dog weighs more than 100 pounds
  • Source of ingredients: Look for all-natural beef chews with no chemicals or additives
  • Pack size: Bully sticks come in all sizes, so choose a smaller pack until you’re confident your dog likes the chews

Which Bully Sticks Last the Longest?

Maybe you have a power chewer in the house and you’re asking yourself which are the longest-lasting bully chews.

Well, as a general rule, long and braided bully sticks will last longest, so look out for these.

Now, before we get down to our bully sticks reviews, where do vets stand regarding bully sticks?

Do Vets Recommend Bully Sticks?

The American Kennel Club view bully sticks as a “great dog treat.” [1]

Most vets consider bully sticks not merely safe, but also beneficial. [2]

If you’re impatient for a quick glimpse at the best of the bunch, we highlight the leading benefits of the top 6 bully sticks, and then we’ll double down with our snapshot reviews of the best bully sticks up for grabs.

  Product Details    
Natural-Farm-Bully-Sticks Best Overall: Natural Farm Bully Sticks • Natural, organic ingredients
• Suitable for all breeds
• Value pack of 25 sticks
Check Price
Cadet-Bully-Sticks-Dog-Treats Runner Up: Cadet Bully Sticks • Low-fat, high-protein sticks
• Made from real bull pizzle
• Supports dental health 
Check Price
Natural-Farm-Odor-Free-Jumbo-Bully-Sticks Best for Big Dog: Natural Farm Jumbo Bully Sticks • No grains or rawhide
• All-natural ingredients
• Cleans and freshens teeth
Check Price
JackPup-6-Inch-Premium-Grade-Odor-Free-Bully-Sticks Long-lasting: Jack & Pup Bully Sticks • Superb sticks for medium breeds
• Promotes teeth and gum hygiene
• Made from grass-fed cattle ingredients
Check Price
Barkworthies-Odor-Free-Bully-Sticks Odor-free: Barkworthies Bully Sticks • Almost odor-free
• Long-lasting sticks
• No artificial preservatives
Check Price
Nature-Gnaws-Small-Bully-Sticks-for-Dogs Best for Small Dogs: Nature Gnaws Small Bully Sticks  • Made from fresh raw ingredients
• No strong smell
• Free of artificial preservatives
Check Price

Barkva.org is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

10 Best Bully Sticks for Dogs

1)Best Overall : Natural Farm Bully Sticks (5 out of 5 stars)

 Natural Farm Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 25
  • Ingredients: Beef
  • Weight: 1.2 pounds

If you’re looking for a bumper value pack of 25 bully sticks, the highly reputable Natural Farm deliver a winning package here.

Made from grass-fed cattle, these beef sticks contain just one ingredient, so you’ll get no nasty additives and your dog will appreciate these organic treats.

Not only will your furball love the way these sticks taste, but they’ll also scour away any plaque and tartar from his teeth, while freshening his breath at the same time.

What We Liked

  • Ingredients from grass-fed beef
  • Freshens breath and cleans teeth
  • Ideal for all breeds

What We Didn’t Like

  • Reasonably short and thin

Rave Review

joshyjosh00

These are awesome sticks. Good size and price. I got these for my 8 week old St. Bernard. And the best part. They don’t smell. I’ve had ones that smelled and know it right away. You can put your nose in the bag and you can’t make out the raw smell as you find in sticks. My pup will out grow these. Can’t wait to get thicker ones from Natural Farm when the time comes. The Standard will size will work for any dog.


2)Runner Up: Cadet Bully Sticks (5 out of 5 Stars)

Cadet Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 12
  • Ingredients: Bull pizzle
  • Weight: 0.75 pounds

Cadet serves up a pack of a dozen bully sticks made from real bull’s pizzle. Packed with protein yet low in fat and calories, you’ll give Fido a treat without causing him to pile on the pounds.

These thick and long-lasting chews are ideal for all breeds, and they are designed to be easily digested.

As with all the best bully sticks, you’ll find these chews are great for your dog’s teeth, cleaning them and also minimizing bad breath.

What We Liked

  • Great for dental health
  • Low in fat and high in protein
  • Made from slow-roasted bull pizzle

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not great for aggressive chewers

Rave Review

redhorse

Although I have tried a few other brands, trying to save money, I will be sticking with Cadet products because I have never been disappointed with their bully sticks. Is there an odor? Yes, of course. Given what bully sticks are, there will always be an odor, but I think the benefits far outweigh smell. I think the Cadet sticks have less smell than other brands I have tried.


3)Best for Big Dogs: Natural Farm Jumbo Bully Sticks (4.5 out of 5 Stars)

Natural Farm Jumbo Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 5
  • Ingredients: Beef pizzle
  • Weight: 14oz 

Next up are some all-natural beef pizzle sticks, again from Natural Farm. Available in multiple sizes and thicknesses, these 12-inch jumbo chews are extra-thick and come in packs of 5.

Made from real beef and containing no grains and no rawhide, you’ll give your pup an all-natural taste sensation, while at the same time promoting great dental health.

This company channels some of its profits into charity and non-profit work for canines, so you’ll not only be giving your dog a treat, but you’ll also be helping other dogs indirectly.

What We Liked

  • No grains or rawhide
  • Made from all-natural beef
  • Removes tartar and plaque from teeth

What We Didn’t Like

  • Sticks are quite thin

Rave Review

AJP

My kind of picky chocolate lab who is 11 months old absolutely loves these. I got the 12 inch pack of 10 and I give him about one every day or two. He has yet to finish one. He can get through about 3-4 inches in an hour or so.


4)Long-Lasting: : Jack & Pup Bully Sticks (4.5 out of 5 Stars)

Jack & Pup Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 5
  • Ingredients: Beef
  • Weight: 3.52oz

If you have a medium breed and you’re looking for bully sticks your pooch won’t whittle down to nothing in minutes flat, Jack & Pup offer the longest-lasting chews we review.

In return for bully sticks built to last, you’ll need to put up with a pretty strong smell. If you can stomach this, your dog will thank you when he gets his teeth around these things.

Promoting sound gum and dental health, these bully sticks are great all-rounders, and they’re also the longest-lasting chews on our shortlist.

What We Liked

  • Perfect for medium breeds
  • Ingredients from grass-fed cattle
  • Great for teeth and gum health

What We Didn’t Like

  • Smell is quite strong

Rave Review

Matthew

This is the first time I have ordered these. I have a large lab and a smaller English Bulldog. My lab is a power chewer that has her usual chews gone in a second. Both of my pups loved these so much and the really did last for hours! They are not hollow , they’re nice and thick. Some are thinner but they last!


5)Odor-Free: Barkworthies Bully Sticks (4 out of 5 Stars)

Barkworthies Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 5
  • Ingredients: Beef pizzle
  • Weight: 4.16oz

When you’re searching for the best bully sticks, you’ll find that many of them have a really strong smell. If you don’t have a cast-iron stomach and you’re looking for odor-free bully sticks, you can’t go wrong with Barkworthies.

Suitable for all breeds, these chews are long-lasting as well as odor-free, so while they aren’t especially cheap, they represent solid overall value.

Free of unnatural additives and containing all-natural beef pizzle, give your hound a taste of the wild without stinking the house out.

What We Liked

  • Long-lasting sticks
  • No pronounced smell
  • Free of artificial preservatives

What We Didn’t Like

  • Some issues with quality control

Rave Review

felonmelonman

I bought these as a gift for my new grandpup Willow. Puppies need to chew and these last her a good long time and she absolutely loves them! Couldn’t be happier with them! Now I’ll get some for my German Shepherd! Bully sticks are a bit pricey and I worried if I could afford them being a disabled senior citizen, but they last so much longer than most traditional chews, I’m going to go for it! Bravo!


6)Best for Small Dogs: Nature Gnaws Small Bully Sticks (4 out of 5 Stars)

 Nature Gnaws Small Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 15
  • Ingredients: Beef
  • Weight: 6.4oz

Nature Gnaws delivers some first-class bully sticks intended for smaller breeds. While these chews are blighted with quality control issues, they nevertheless make your best bet if you have a dinky dog at home.

Made using organic and raw ingredients, these beef chews contain no rawhide and no unwanted chemicals either.

With each pack bulging with 15 chews, why not give your furball a treat?

What We Liked

  • Made from fresh raw ingredients
  • No chemicals or rawhide
  • Minimal odor

What We Didn’t Like

  • Some quality control concerns

Rave Review

Name

We have found this “bully stick” product the best of three selections we have tried on Amazon. Nice thickness to the bully sticks. On other products, thickness varied with a significant number of thin diameter pieces. Longest lasting of the bully sticks we have tried.


7) Best Bully Sticks (4 out of 5 stars)

Best Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 25
  • Ingredients: Beef
  • Weight: 14oz

As we pass the midpoint of our bully stick reviews, a bumper pack from the Best Bully Sticks Store.

These rawhide-free chews come with a subtle natural scent your dog will love. As an inbuilt kicker, the smell of these sticks won’t turn your stomach either. The same can’t be said for all bully sticks.

The beef chews are designed to be digested with ease, and you’ll give your dog a high-protein treat that also buffs up his teeth and gums.

What We Liked

  • All-natural scent
  • Rawhide-free
  • Made from high-protein beef

What We Didn’t Like

  • Not good for bigger breeds

Rave Review

NSB

These are very high quality bully sticks! After purchasing a few different brands of bully sticks from our local pet store, it was clear our Toy Fox Terrier, Bandit, had a new favorite treat- what wasn’t very clear was the quality of the treats he was eating. These sticks are all natural- not smoked or treated like the pet store brands.


8) Pawstruck Bully Sticks (4 out of 5 stars)

Pawstruck Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: Variable (sold by weight)
  • Ingredients: Beef pizzle
  • Weight: 8oz

Pawstruck has some great pet products including these all-natural bully sticks. How do they shape up, then?

Made from premium ingredients and containing no chemicals, you’ll be giving your dog everything he needs and nothing he doesn’t.

Sized evenly and thick enough your dog won’t destroy them in minutes flat, these beef pizzle chews are available in a range of sizes to suit, and multi-dog households will appreciate the ability to buy these things in bulk at a keen discount.

What We Liked

  • Consistent weight and thickness
  • Made from free-range, grass-fed ingredients
  • Wholesale options available

What We Didn’t Like

  • Sticks are quite skinny

Rave Review

Sarah McLoughlin

I feed my dog one bully stick per day. I normally buy bully sticks at my local pet store but it’s a huge pain to go to and it’s crazy expensive! I finally had the genius idea to check Amazon and these were the first ones I bought. These are so much better and cheaper than what I normally get! My dog absolutely loves them. Pawstruck has got a lifelong customer. No way I’m sitting in traffic anymore to go to the store.


9) Downtown Pet Supply Bully Sticks (4.5 out of 5 stars)

Downtown Pet Supply Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 5
  • Ingredients: Beef
  • Weight: 7.2oz

Downtown Pet Supply has a deep bench of pet gear, including these beef-flavored bully sticks well worth popping on your shortlist.

Although these chews are not cheap, they’re ideal if your dog is an aggressive chewer that typically splinters cheaper bully sticks.

Extra-thick and suitable for all breeds and life stages, these are some of the best bully sticks you’ll find.

What We Liked

  • No bones and no splintering
  • Extra-thick for power chewers
  • Made from 100% beef

What We Didn’t Like

  • Reasonably expensive

Rave Review

Dianne

My 200+ pound dog could smell the treats through the delivery box. It took him several hours to consume the giant bully stick. Which is a long time for his extremely strong bite. The ad states there is a scent to the sticks. I will probably give his next bully stick outside. Im glad it stinks, my dog love it.


10) Amazing Dog Treats Bully Sticks (4 out of 5 stars)

Amazing Dog Treats Bully Sticks Packaging

Features

  • Number of sticks: 15
  • Ingredients: Beef
  • Weight: 11.7oz

Last but not least in today’s showcase of the best bully sticks come these all-beef chews from the Amazing Dog Treats Store.

With no additives and no chemicals in these organic chews, your dog will easily digest these sticks, even if he has stomach sensitivities.

The chews will also help stimulate your dog’s teeth and gums for an all-round treat at a reasonable price point.

What We Liked

  • Free of chemicals and additives
  • Encourages strong dental health
  • Rich in protein

What We Didn’t Like

  • Pretty strong smell

Rave Review

Name

Yes they do smell, but if you buy bully sticks you will know your dog likes the smell. these are very dense, which means it will take time for your pooch to get through.

I have tried at least 25 different brands and these are a great value. my 2 100lb German shepherds love them and takes at least 10-15 minutes for them to get through a stick. I will stick 🙂 with these!!


Sources

[1] https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/nutrition/why-bully-sticks-are-a-great-treat-for-dogs/

[2] https://www.caninejournal.com/are-bully-sticks-good-for-dogs/

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases - at no cost to you, allowing us to continue our work.

Leave a Comment